Categories

About

Santa's Cookie Plate is a festive, holiday-inspired cocktail that celebrates the Italian cookie tradition through three distinctly complementary ingredients: Biscotti Liqueur, blood orange liqueur, and walnut bitters. The combination evokes a holiday cookie plate in liquid form — the warm almond sweetness of Italian biscotti, the vivid ruby-red citrus of blood orange, and the earthy depth of walnut — creating a cocktail that is as visually striking (blood-orange-red against the pale biscotti base) as it is complex and delicious.

The Holiday Cookie Cocktail Concept

Holiday cocktails occupy a special niche in the cocktail world: they are expected to be festive, warming, and resonant with the flavors that define seasonal celebration — cinnamon, vanilla, citrus, nut, chocolate, warm spice. The Santa's Cookie Plate captures this spirit through a specifically Italian-American lens: the biscotti tradition (cantucci, amaretti, pizzelle) that forms the backbone of Italian-American holiday baking, expressed through Faretti Biscotti Famosi liqueur; the blood orange tradition of winter citrus, when blood oranges (tarocco, moro, and sanguinello varieties) ripen across Sicily and the Italian south from December through March, coinciding precisely with the holiday season; and the walnut, a nut with deep roots in Italian Christmas baking and a particular affinity for both almond and citrus flavors. Together the three ingredients — almond-pastry warmth, blood-orange vibrancy, and walnut depth — create a cocktail that genuinely evokes the sensory experience of a well-curated Italian holiday cookie plate. See the full Biscotti Liqueur collection for more Faretti-based cocktails. The recipe was developed by Cocktail Contessa and featured on Cocktail Contessa's holiday cocktail collection. For blood orange cocktail inspiration, Liquor.com's blood orange cocktail collection is an excellent resource.

Blood Orange and Biscotti: A Sicilian Pairing

Blood orange and almond are a classic Sicilian flavor pairing — the island produces both in abundance and has combined them in sweets and pastries for centuries. Blood orange's distinctive anthocyanin-driven flavor is more complex than regular orange: not just sweet citrus but a berry-like, slightly tart, deeply fragrant quality that has earned it the "blood" epithet and made it one of the most prized citrus fruits in the world. Blood orange liqueur (such as Solerno, the Sicilian-made blood orange liqueur based on the IGP-protected tarocco orange) provides this flavor in an easily incorporated format, and its vivid color adds visual drama to any cocktail it joins. The walnut bitters provide grounding: earthy, slightly tannic, with the gentle bitterness that prevents the combination of two sweet liqueurs from tipping into cloying territory.

How to Make and Serve

Stir all ingredients with ice in a mixing glass and strain into a chilled coupe or rocks glass over ice. The blood orange liqueur will color the drink a beautiful deep amber-red. Garnish with a blood orange wheel (when in season) or a strip of orange peel. See MixDrinkEnjoy's cocktail techniques guide for stirring technique. The Biscotti Manhattan and the Old Fashioned are stirred spirit-forward alternatives for holiday occasions when something less sweet is desired.